Prevalence of Alexithymia and Depression in Medical Students Necessitate Attention

Article Information

Marium Aftab1*, Razia A2, Komal Tirath3, Ayesha Jawad4, Rida Saleem5

1Dow University of Health Sciences, Nanakwara, Karachi, Karachi City, Sindh, Pakistan

2Department of Family and Community Medicine, King Khalid University, Abha, Saudi Arabia

3Medical student, Ziauddin Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan

4Medical student at Karachi Medical and Dental College, Karachi City, Sindh, Pakistan

5Medical student, Sir Said College of Medical Sciences Affiliated with Jinnah Medical and Dental University, Shaheed-e-Millat Rd, Bihar Muslim Society BMCHS Sharafabad, Karachi, Karachi City, Sindh, Pakistan

*Corresponding Author: Marium Aftab, Dow University of Health Sciences, Nanakwara, Karachi, Karachi City, Sindh, Pakistan

Received: 15 August 2023; Accepted: 21 September 2023; Published: 14 November 2023

Citation:

Marium Aftab, Razia Aftab Ahmed, Komal Tirath, Ayesha Jawad, Rida Saleem. Prevalence of Alexithymia and Depression in Medical Students Necessitate Attention. Journal of Psychiatry and Psychiatric Disorders. 7 (2023): 191-200.

Share at Facebook

Abstract

Background: Medical students are vulnerable to psychological problems like alexithymia and depression due to the pressure of time commitments, rapidly changing knowledge, exposure to emotionally challenging experiences, and meeting high expectations from society. Our study aims to find the prevalence of these problems in medical students in Karachi, Pakistan.

Methodology: This cross-sectional study includes 414 undergraduate medical students from multiple medical universities. The study tool was uploaded on Google survey; a questionnaire with background characteristics, TAS-20 scale for alexithymia prevalence, and PHQ-9 for depression prevalence.

Results: Out of 414 participants, 300 (72.5%) were females and 114 (27.5%) males. The majority were between the age range 21-33 (59%), among them 222(54%) from governmental medical universities and 192 (46%) from the private sector. Most had no chronic disease or financial problems. Alexithymia was found in 268 students (64.7%), while 15.9% were in the category of possible alexithymia. Depression was present in 291 (70%) students, depression severity score was 14±7. External-oriented thinking was higher than other subscales of alexithymia. Alexithymia had a statistically significant association with age, female gender, education level, lower GPA, lack of physical training, and depression. In turn, depression had a significant relation with the female gender, higher education level, and poor exam performance. Regression analysis showed that severe depression was a strong predictor of Alexithymia with a p-value of <0.001.

Conclusion: The study revealed a very high prevalence of alexithymia and depression in medical students necessitating attention because their wellbeing means physicians’ well-being and a path to strengthening patient care and professionalism.

Keywords

Undergraduate Medical Students; Prevalence; Alexithymia; Depression; Attention

Undergraduate Medical Students articles; Prevalence articles; Alexithymia articles; Depression articles; Attention articles

Undergraduate Medical Students articles Undergraduate Medical Students Research articles Undergraduate Medical Students review articles Undergraduate Medical Students PubMed articles Undergraduate Medical Students PubMed Central articles Undergraduate Medical Students 2023 articles Undergraduate Medical Students 2024 articles Undergraduate Medical Students Scopus articles Undergraduate Medical Students impact factor journals Undergraduate Medical Students Scopus journals Undergraduate Medical Students PubMed journals Undergraduate Medical Students medical journals Undergraduate Medical Students free journals Undergraduate Medical Students best journals Undergraduate Medical Students top journals Undergraduate Medical Students free medical journals Undergraduate Medical Students famous journals Undergraduate Medical Students Google Scholar indexed journals Prevalence articles Prevalence Research articles Prevalence review articles Prevalence PubMed articles Prevalence PubMed Central articles Prevalence 2023 articles Prevalence 2024 articles Prevalence Scopus articles Prevalence impact factor journals Prevalence Scopus journals Prevalence PubMed journals Prevalence medical journals Prevalence free journals Prevalence best journals Prevalence top journals Prevalence free medical journals Prevalence famous journals Prevalence Google Scholar indexed journals Alexithymia articles Alexithymia Research articles Alexithymia review articles Alexithymia PubMed articles Alexithymia PubMed Central articles Alexithymia 2023 articles Alexithymia 2024 articles Alexithymia Scopus articles Alexithymia impact factor journals Alexithymia Scopus journals Alexithymia PubMed journals Alexithymia medical journals Alexithymia free journals Alexithymia best journals Alexithymia top journals Alexithymia free medical journals Alexithymia famous journals Alexithymia Google Scholar indexed journals Depression articles Depression Research articles Depression review articles Depression PubMed articles Depression PubMed Central articles Depression 2023 articles Depression 2024 articles Depression Scopus articles Depression impact factor journals Depression Scopus journals Depression PubMed journals Depression medical journals Depression free journals Depression best journals Depression top journals Depression free medical journals Depression famous journals Depression Google Scholar indexed journals Attention articles Attention Research articles Attention review articles Attention PubMed articles Attention PubMed Central articles Attention 2023 articles Attention 2024 articles Attention Scopus articles Attention impact factor journals Attention Scopus journals Attention PubMed journals Attention medical journals Attention free journals Attention best journals Attention top journals Attention free medical journals Attention famous journals Attention Google Scholar indexed journals Toronto Alexithymia Scale articles Toronto Alexithymia Scale Research articles Toronto Alexithymia Scale review articles Toronto Alexithymia Scale PubMed articles Toronto Alexithymia Scale PubMed Central articles Toronto Alexithymia Scale 2023 articles Toronto Alexithymia Scale 2024 articles Toronto Alexithymia Scale Scopus articles Toronto Alexithymia Scale impact factor journals Toronto Alexithymia Scale Scopus journals Toronto Alexithymia Scale PubMed journals Toronto Alexithymia Scale medical journals Toronto Alexithymia Scale free journals Toronto Alexithymia Scale best journals Toronto Alexithymia Scale top journals Toronto Alexithymia Scale free medical journals Toronto Alexithymia Scale famous journals Toronto Alexithymia Scale Google Scholar indexed journals Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions articles Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions Research articles Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions review articles Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions PubMed articles Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions PubMed Central articles Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions 2023 articles Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions 2024 articles Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions Scopus articles Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions impact factor journals Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions Scopus journals Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions PubMed journals Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions medical journals Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions free journals Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions best journals Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions top journals Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions free medical journals Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions famous journals Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions Google Scholar indexed journals sociability articles sociability Research articles sociability review articles sociability PubMed articles sociability PubMed Central articles sociability 2023 articles sociability 2024 articles sociability Scopus articles sociability impact factor journals sociability Scopus journals sociability PubMed journals sociability medical journals sociability free journals sociability best journals sociability top journals sociability free medical journals sociability famous journals sociability Google Scholar indexed journals submissiveness articles submissiveness Research articles submissiveness review articles submissiveness PubMed articles submissiveness PubMed Central articles submissiveness 2023 articles submissiveness 2024 articles submissiveness Scopus articles submissiveness impact factor journals submissiveness Scopus journals submissiveness PubMed journals submissiveness medical journals submissiveness free journals submissiveness best journals submissiveness top journals submissiveness free medical journals submissiveness famous journals submissiveness Google Scholar indexed journals intimacy articles intimacy Research articles intimacy review articles intimacy PubMed articles intimacy PubMed Central articles intimacy 2023 articles intimacy 2024 articles intimacy Scopus articles intimacy impact factor journals intimacy Scopus journals intimacy PubMed journals intimacy medical journals intimacy free journals intimacy best journals intimacy top journals intimacy free medical journals intimacy famous journals intimacy Google Scholar indexed journals

Article Details

Abbreviations:

TAS-20 scale: Toronto Alexithymia Scale; PHQ-9: Patient Health Questionnaire with nine questions

1. Introduction

People suffering from alexithymia are not able to identify and describe their own emotions; they know very little about their feelings and are mostly unable to link them with memories, fantasies, or specific situations [1]. The real problem for people with alexithymia is that not only do they have no words for their emotions, but they also lack the emotions themselves. Alexithymia represents a cluster of cognitive traits that include difficulty identifying feelings, difficulty describing feelings to others, externally oriented thinking (preference for focusing on external events rather than inner experiences) and limited imaginative capacity. Therefore, people with alexithymia may demonstrate deficiencies in emotional awareness and communication and show little insight into their feelings, symptoms, and motivation [2]. Moreover, alexithymia is linked to deficits in empathy, i.e., the ability to take the perspective of others and to understand others’ feelings and intentions [1,3]. An inability to accurately understand and describe one’s internal affective states will thus lead to difficulties empathizing with others’ feelings [4]. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders does not list alexithymia as a mental disorder. It is a multidimensional personality trait, and each person's level of intensity will vary, and everyone with the condition is not the same; some have gaps and distortions in the typical emotions felt, some may feel an emotion but don’t know which, whereas others muddle signs of certain emotions for something else and may intensify and misinterpret ordinary bodily sensations associated with emotional arousal as physical disease. People with higher scores for alexithymia can endure continuous problems in processing emotions at a cognitive level and regulating them, putting them at risk of developing psychiatric conditions. It has been documented that alexithymia is a major risk factor for psychological distress and chronic psychopathology. Many studies show that multiple psychiatric disorders overlap with alexithymia, such as alexithymia is found to be associated with eating disorders, depression, anxiety disorders, and substance abuse [5-8] also, a study emphasized a significant positive association of alexithymia with interpersonal problems regarding; assertiveness, sociability, submissiveness, intimacy, responsibility, and control [9]. People with alexithymia show a limited ability to experience positive emotions. As a result, many of these individuals are anhedonic [8]. Studies also relate higher scores of alexithymia with some physical health problems like heart-related problems, hypertension, diabetes, and functional dyspepsia, etc. [10,11] also increasing age, lack of family support, divorce, single and low social status is associated with alexithymia [12,13]. The fact that the presence of alexithymia in a subject may decrease the feeling of empathy may be detrimental to future doctor’s medical practice that emphasizes professional behavior, with empathy being one of the essential elements; this augments the necessity of early recognition of the condition and thereby to help these students in getting timely management.

Like alexithymia, depression is also linked to numerous other physical and psychological diseases, and if severe, it can lead to suicidal tendencies in students. Moreover, depression has been documented to be associated with alexithymia in several studies [6,7]. A higher prevalence of both conditions may lead to augmented student suffering and poorer performance. Clinically relevant alexithymia affects approximately ten percent (7.7 -9.1%) of the general population. [13,14]. Both alexithymia and depression are documented to be even more in young students [15], and it is found to be a major problem faced by students, especially medical students; this can be explained by the hard work and dedication required in their studies and practical training [16,17]. Considering the facts revealed by various studies that students with alexithymia and depression may have poor academic performance and that they may have difficulty in adjusting with fellow students and health care team, that could result in maladaptive behaviors like; smoking, substance abuse, lack of physical activity, and other psychological problems [16-18]; it seems important to highlight the prevalence of these conditions in medical students studying at various medical universities in Karachi, Pakistan and also important is to find out the associated factors with these conditions.

Accordingly, this study was planned to appraise the prevalence and severity scores of alexithymia and depression among medical students at randomly selected medical universities in Karachi, Pakistan; along with this, it aimed to find the association with some of the factors mentioned in previous studies for these two important psychological problems.

Study Aims and Objectives:

  1. To assess the prevalence of alexithymia and depression among medical students at several medical universities in Karachi, Pakistan
  2. To investigate the potential association of alexithymia with factors such as gender, living with parents, year of study, residential status, grade point average (GPA), smoking, physical inactivity, history of mental illness, and chronic illness among medical students.
  3. To find potential association of depression with the same socio-demographic factors such as gender, living with parents, year of study, residential status, grade point average (GPA), smoking, physical inactivity, history of mental illness, and chronic illness among medical students.
  4. To study depression as a predictor of Alexithymia.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1 Study Design and Setting

This is an analytical cross-sectional, questionnaire-based survey carried out among undergraduate medical students in several Medical Colleges in Karachi, Pakistan.

2.2 Study Population inclusion and exclusion criteria

Medical students in all five years of undergraduate studies in several medical universities in Karachi, Pakistan, were invited to participate in this study. Students who refused to participate and forms with missing data were excluded.

2.3 Sample Size

The sample size was calculated using the Roasoft online sample size calculator [19], assuming the total population of approachable medical students = 10500 (there are 19 medical colleges in Karachi. Collectively 2100 students are admitted each year in all these colleges; multiplying them by 5 (undergraduate years of study), we can calculate it to be around 10,500 medical students), the prevalence of alexithymia = 50% (as it is not known from previous studies), 95% confidence interval and 5% acceptable errors, the sample calculated was 371. Since 414 students responded, all were included.

2.4 Sampling Technique

The study tool was uploaded in the Google survey form. Four students from various medical colleges participated in posting the forms; they used simple random sampling technique for posting them to various medical colleges. Participants were assured about the anonymity and confidentiality of their responses to the questionnaire. The responding students were then grouped according to their year of study.

2.5 The study tool

The study was a questionnaire with three parts:

  1. Background characteristics: including; age, gender, Cumulative GPA, student educational level, Medical college, whether private or governmental, BMI, marital status, smoking status, physical training, family income, housing along with the presence of any chronic condition like diabetes, hypertension, asthma, cardiac, neurological, psychiatric condition. Liver or kidney diseases
  2. The second part contained: the Toronto Alexithymia Scale 20 (TAS-20) to assess the prevalence of alexithymia. A self-report scale that assesses two affective facets (difficulty fantasizing and difficulty emotionalizing) in addition to three cognitive facets. Based on these facets, an affective and a cognitive dimension of alexithymia can be distinguished. The TAS-20 is a self-report scale comprising 20 items rated using a five-point Likert scale where 1=strongly disagree and 5=strongly agree. The cutoff scores on the TAS-20 are ≤51 for the low end (meaning no alexithymia) and ≥61 for the high end (alexithymia). Scores between 52 and 60 indicate possible alexithymia [23]. The TAS-20 has three subscales:
    1. Difficulty Describing Feelings (DDF) subscale measures difficulty describing emotions. 5 items – 2, 4, 11, 12, 17.
    2. Difficulty Identifying Feeling (DIF) subscale measures difficulty identifying emotions. 7 items – 1, 3, 6, 7, 9, 13, 14.
    3. Externally Oriented Thinking (EOT) subscale measures individuals’ tendency to focus their attention externally. 8 items – 5, 8, 10, 15, 16, 18, 19, 20.
  1. The third part contained: The Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9) is a self-administered questionnaire used to screen depression and assess its severity. The items were scored on a 4-point scale rated from 0 (not at all) to 3 (nearly every day). The cut-off score was 10 (PHQ-9 ≥10), indicating that a patient had a positive screening test for depression. The total score was classified into diagnostic algorithms according to DSM-IV as the following: a score from 10 to 14 was considered moderate depression, 15–19 was moderately severe depression, and 20–27 indicated severe depression 24.

2.6 Statistical Analysis Plan

Data will be analyzed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) program, version 26. Descriptive statistics, including percentages, means, ranges, and standard deviations, will be used to describe data regarding alexithymia and depression. The t-test will detect the difference between male and female students regarding major studied variables. Pearson and Spearman correlation coefficients will use to examine the association between alexithymia and other studied variables. Multiple regression analysis was used to detect the variables that best correlate with alexithymia. All statistical assumptions were met. Statistical significance was set at P≤.05; Reporting followed the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) statement for cross-sectional studies.

3. Results

Out of 414 participants, 300 (72.5%) were females, and 14 (27.5%) were males, with the majority between the age range of 21-33 (n =244, 59%; details in Figure-1). Among the participants, 222 (54%) belonged to the public sector medical universities, whereas 192 (46%) were from the private sector. The responses were received from all medical students, in which the majority were in the 4th year of education with 142 (34%), followed by the final year 112 (27%). Only 10(2%) responses were received from the first-year students. Most of the student’s family income was between 100,001 PKR per month to greater than 200,000 PKR. The majority were free of any chronic illness. (Table 1).

Table 1: Background Characteristics of the Participants

Variables

Frequency

Percent

Age

less than 18

5

1.2

18-20

88

21.3

21-23

244

58.9

24-26

72

17.4

greater than 26

5

1.2

Gender

female

300

72.5

male

114

27.5

GPA

less than 1.5

7

1.7

1.5-2.49

75

18.1

2.5-3.5

242

58.5

more than 3.5

90

21.7

Education

1st

10

2.4

2nd

75

18.1

3rd

75

18.1

4thz

142

34.3

final

112

27.1

College/University

private

192

46.4

government

222

53.6

BMI

less than 18.5

65

15.7

18.5-24.99

234

56.5

25-29.99

83

20

30-34.99

21

5.1

35-39.99

8

1.9

40 or more

3

0.7

Monthly family income

less than 50k

41

9.9

50k-100k

118

28.5

101k-200k

137

33.1

more than 200k

118

28.5

Housing

rented

74

17.9

own

235

56.8

student hostel

105

25.4

chronic illness

yes

30

7.2

no

384

92.8

The prevalence of alexithymia was estimated to be 64.7%, while 15.9% were found to be in the category of possible alexithymia. Depression was present in 291, that is, 70% of students, and the depression severity score was 14 ± 7 among these students. The details of these are shown in Table 2.

Table 2: Frequency of Alexithymia and Depression among Medical Students.

 

Frequency

Percentage

Alexithymia

No Alexithymia

80

19.4

Possible Alexithymia

66

15.9

Alexithymia

268

64.7

 

414

100

Depression

Yes

291

70%

No

123

30%

   

414

100

fortune-biomass-feedstock

Figure 2: Alexithymia prevalence.

Studying the individual questions (2, 4, 11, 12, 17), it was found that the mean for difficulty describing feelings (DDF) subscale response was = 3.414, while the response to questions representing difficulty identifying feeling (DIF) subscale (1, 3, 6, 7, 9, 13, 14) was = 3.09, and those showing externally oriented thinking (EOT) subscale (5, 8, 10, 15, 16, 18, 19, 20. was estimated to be = 3.57. As shown in Table 3, this indicates that the students have more problems with externally oriented thinking in comparison to other subscales; next was DD,F and least was DIF.

Table 3: response to different items in the Toronto Alexithymia Scale (TAS-20) by students (n=414).

Q-#

Items

Mean

SD

Min

Max

1

I am often confused about what emotion I am feeling

3.26

1.25

1

5

2

It is difficult for me to find the right words for my feelings

3.5

1.29

1

5

3

I have physical sensations that even doctors don’t understand

2.6

1.34

1

5

4

I am able to describe my feelings easily

3.47

1.23

1

5

5

I prefer to analyze problems rather than just describe them

3.78

1.09

1

5

6

When I am upset. I don’t know if I am sad, frightened, or angry

3.28

1.37

1

5

7

I am often puzzled by sensations in my body

2.83

1.26

1

5

8

I prefer to just let things happen rather than to understand why they turned out that way

3.21

1.4

1

5

9

I have feelings that I can’t quite identify

3.06

1.22

1

5

10

Being in touch with emotions is essential

3.79

1.01

1

5

11

I find it hard to describe how I feel about people

3.31

1.26

1

5

12

People tell me to describe my feelings more

3.09

1.27

1

5

13

I don’t know what’s going on inside me

3.22

1.38

1

5

14

I often don’t know why I am angry

3.38

1.4

1

5

15

I prefer talking to people about their daily activities rather than their feelings.

3.36

1.4

1

5

16

I prefer to watch “light” entertainment shows rather than psychological dramas

3.5

1.34

1

5

17

It is difficult for me to reveal my innermost feelings, even to close friends

3.7

1.34

1

5

18

I can feel close to someone, even in moments of silence

3.55

1.07

1

5

19

I find examination of my feelings useful in solving personal problems

3.55

0.95

1

5

20

I look for hidden meanings in movies or plays

3.79

1.15

1

5

The potential association of alexithymia was investigated with different factors such as age, gender, education, grade points, smoking status, physical inactivity and chronic diseases among medical students. A statistically significant association of alexithymia was seen in age, education level, GPA, physical training and depression (Table 4).

Table 4: Association of Alexithymia with Background Characteristics.

Variables

No Alexithymia (n=80)

Possible Alexithymia (n=65)

Alexithymia (n=269)

p-value

Age

0.026*

Less than 18 years

0

1

4

18-20

10

8

70

21-23

49

41

154

24-26

19

13

40

greater than 26

2

2

1

Gender

0.056

Female

54

41

205

Male

26

24

64

Student Educational level:

0.001*

First-year

0

0

10

Second year

8

12

55

Third year

10

5

60

Fourth year

38

28

76

Final year

24

20

68

GPA

<0.001*

less than 1.5

0

0

7

1.5-2.49

2

6

67

2.5-3.5

58

35

149

more than 3.5

20

24

46

Smoking status

0.598

Smoker

5

7

21

Nonsmoker

75

58

248

Physical training

0.033*

Never

28

29

105

Once a week

20

10

63

two times a week

17

12

68

three times a week

6

3

21

More than three times

9

11

12

chronic illness

0.934

Yes

6

4

20

No

74

61

249

Depression

<0.001*

Yes

24

28

229

No

56

27

40

*Statistically significant value by chi-square test.

The potential association of depression with different factors was also investigated, and it was revealed that it is significantly related to the female gender, students’ education level, and their performance, that is their GPA.

Table 5: Association of Depression with Background Characteristics.

 

Depression

 

Variables

Yes (n=291)

No (n=123)

p-value

Age

0.227

Less than 18 years

3

2

18-20

70

18

21-23

169

75

24-26

46

26

greater than 26

3

2

Gender

0.028*

Female

220

80

Male

71

43

Student Educational level:

0.003*

First year

7

3

Second year

58

17

Third year

64

11

Fourth year

87

55

Final year

75

37

GPA

<0.001*

less than 1.5

6

1

1.5-2.49

72

3

2.5-3.5

160

82

more than 3.5

53

37

Smoking status

0.938

Smoker

23

10

Nonsmoker

268

113

Physical training

0.007*

Never

111

51

Once a week

67

26

two times a week

79

18

three times a week

18

12

More than three times

16

16

chronic illness

0.52

Yes

20

10

No

271

113

Regression analysis confirmed a statistically significant association between alexithymia scores and depression among the medical students, as 229 students with depression also had scores representing alexithymia, while 38 students with depression had scores showing possible alexithymia. The regression analysis also revealed that severe depression could be a predictor of Alexithymia with p value less than 0.001.

Table 6: Regression Analysis of Depression as a predictor of Alexithymia.

 

Severe Depression

Without Depression

Odds Ratio (OR)

95%CI (Lower–Upper)

p-value

Possible Alexithymia

38

27

0.075

(0.042 – 0.134)

<0.001*

Alexithymia

229

40

0.246

(0.135 – 0.447)

<0.001*

*Statistically significant p-value

4.Discussion

The prevalence of alexithymia (64.7%) in our participating students was found to be relatively higher than in many other studies from different regions of the world. The prevalence of alexithymia among the participants was found to be 26.9% in medical students at Riyadh, KSA [21], similar to 24.6% in medical students at Jordanian university [22], while it was slightly higher at 49% among medical students at Jeddah KSA [23] and found to be at 47.4% in medical students at Abha, KSA [24]. The prevalence of alexithymia was documented to be 34% in a study among Chinese medical students, [25] a study from undergraduate students from the university of Information Technology, Engineering and Management Sciences in Pakistan reported that 33% of their participating students had alexithymia scores [26]. The same researcher found the prevalence to be 93% in males and 87% in female participants from the general adult population [27]. A study from Umm AlQura University, Makkah, KSA revealed a prevalence of 56.5%, much closer to our finding [28]. These different prevalence rates, widely varying from 24.6% to 93% may be explained by the fact that there is a difference in coping with emotions across different cultures, different age groups, and different levels of psychiatric illnesses, which could influence the prevalence of alexithymia. Furthermore, studies do reveal that there is some difference noted in alexithymia prevalence between Western and Asian cultures [29,30]. A study explains that one of the reasons for higher scores of alexithymia prevalence in Asian countries may reflect the fact that; parents in western cultures have been noted to express positive emotions and display physical affection more than Asian parents who are less eloquent. Therefore, higher scores of alexithymia in the present study may be due to the different social and ethical values in Pakistani culture and may reflect the fact that a higher prevalence of depression (70%) was also found in our participants. Another rationale could be that in the current study, a relatively more number of participants belonged to government institutes, and these students pursue not only one of the most difficult professions of specialized training with respect to course duration, competition, and emotional demands but also face difficulties as curriculum in government medical collages is mainly comprised of traditional courses that demand more hard work and higher stress level. The subscale scores for alexithymia in our subjects reflect higher problems in the domain of externally oriented thinking (EOT) in comparison to other subscales; difficulty describing feelings (DDF) and difficulty identifying feelings (DIF); this is in accordance with many studies showing the similar finding of having higher EOT in comparison to DDF and DIF [22,31]. A Japanese study in a large sample of 2718 found that DIF and DDF scores are high for teenagers, but decrease with age. While they found an almost linear positive correlation between age and the EOT scores [32]. Different studies related to gender differences in alexithymia are varied and confusing. Some reported non-significant relation of alexithymia with gender [16,23]. Few studies report higher prevalence among males in comparison to women [11,26,33] while more studies show higher scores for women similar to the present study [13,16,21,22,24,28,29], as narrated in a previous article; this could be explained by the fact 29 that in Pakistani culture females have to pay more attention on other family members’ need in extended families and be responsible for household duties along with their studies, also they are shy to express their feelings, and emotions openly. Besides the female gender, our study shows a statistically significant association of alexithymia with age, education level, GPA, physical training and depression. These findings are consistent with many other types of research. The association of alexithymia with increasing age has been documented in many other studies [13,32]. Higher scores for alexithymia were seen in students studying in the third and the fourth year of Medical college; these are the initial years of the clerkship period when they start facing actual patients and come across the sufferings of patients and have a higher load of studies as well. Other researchers have also observed a similar finding in medical students [35]. Studies do report that subjects with chronic diseases were more likely to have alexithymia24, 34 However, in the present study, we did not find any significant association between alexithymia and chronic disease; this may be because mostly our subjects were young people free of any chronic physical illness.

The association of alexithymia with lower educational grades (GPA) is consistent with many other studies [23,28]; students with high levels of alexithymia are reported to be more negatively affected by university stress compared to peers with low or no alexithymia and higher levels of stress can have detrimental impacts on academic performance; also lower grades themselves may lead to stress, anxiety, and depression that in turn lead to higher scores of alexithymia [16,36,37]. Our study result is in line with other studies documenting that students who do not participate in physical activities were more likely to suffer from alexithymia and had higher TAS-20 scores than those who actively participated in physical activities [21,23]. This could be explained by the known fact that engaging in physical activity may help reduce symptoms of depression [37-39]. While a similar study done at Abha, Saudi Arabia, failed to show any such significant association [24]. Depression prevalence was also found to be very high (70%) in our study participants, with severity scores showing moderate to severe problem (14 ± 7) among them. This is very close to a similar study in medical students [24]. A study from Pakistan revealed almost the same prevalence of depression in medical students, and it was also more in female students [40]. A systemic review also finds a high prevalence of depression in medical students and recommends early intervention to help them [41]. A significantly strong association was found between alexithymia and depression in our samples. This was also confirmed by regression analysis, and depression appeared as a strong predictor of alexithymia, especially for subjects showing higher scores on the PHQ-9 scale. In literature, it has been found that depression and alexithymia are different but highly related constructs [42,43]. Most of the studies, including that from India [42], Finland China [15], Australia [32], Jordan [22], Lebanon [44], and Saudi Arabia [21,23] are coincident with this finding. Whatever the reason for this association; whether they coexist or alexithymia is a consequence of depression, the fact revealed in our study, supported by the same finding from other global regions; is that these two conditions cause enormous enduring by the students not only from the condition per se but also from the sequel from these leading to lower performance level, other psychological and physical illnesses. The medical students considered to be the future saviors of the community may not be able to accomplish as experts in their practical life especially lacking empathy, which is considered the cornerstone in medical practice; this may have a detrimental effect on the care of patients.

5. Conclusion

The present study shows a very high prevalence of both alexithymia and depression in students studying at various medical schools in Karachi, Pakistan. Among 414 undergraduate medical students who participated in the study, we found that 64.7 percent have TAS-20 scores consistent with alexithymia, while 70% suffered from depression according to the PHQ-9 depression scale. It highlights a statistically significant association of alexithymia and depression with female gender, education level, and GPA, while alexithymia was also significantly related to age and physical training. We emphasize further temporal studies to confirm these associations and highly recommend a prompt and appropriate strategy to help these silent sufferers. Our study stresses developing effective policies to screen, develop awareness programs and provide appropriate treatment to these students through psychological intervention and expert treatment.

Limitations and Strengths of the Study

There are a few limitations and weaknesses in our studies; firstly, as it is a self-reporting survey that requires self-awareness and knowledge about themself and the individuals with alexithymia may lack this insight, also biases from the respondents can be there, those with depression may exaggerate and respond more negatively. Another drawback could be due to the fact that this is a cross-sectional study design that does not allow conclusions to be made concerning relationships among variables and possible causal mechanisms; such issues can only be addressed via suitably designed longitudinal studies, The high scores of depression and alexithymia in our study provide evidence for identifying these disorders in medical students in Karachi, Pakistan, where only a few studies are available in this context. It also calls attention to the need for further research in this respect and for making policies that implement needful steps to help our future redeemers.

Recommendation:

Our study strongly calls attention to this high prevalence of alexithymia and depression in undergraduate medical students. Appropriate management after identifying these students who are silently suffering may secure their future. It is known that timely treatment with pharmacological and non-pharmacological measures at an early stage may lead to mentally healthy professionals who can provide high-quality care to the community.

Conflict of Interest:

None

References

  1. FeldmanHall O, Dalgleish T, Mobbs D. Alexithymia decreases altruism in real social decisions. Cortex 49 (2013): 899-904.
  2. Ricciardi L, Demartini B, Fotopoulou A, et al. Alexithymia in Neurological Disease: A Review. The Journal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences 27 (2015): 179-187.
  3. Valdespino A, Antezana L, Ghane M, et al. Alexithymia as a trans diagnostic precursor to empathy abnormalities: the functional role of the insula. Front. Psychol 8 (2017): 2234.
  4. Bird G, Viding E. The self to other model of empathy: providing a new framework for understanding empathy impairments in psychopathy, autism, and alexithymia. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 47 (2014): 520-532.
  5. Cochrane CE, Brewerton TD, Wilson DB, et al. Alexithymia in the eating disorders. The International Journal of Eating Disorders 14 (1993): 219-222.
  6. Honkalampi K, Hintikka J, Laukkanen E, et al. Alexithymia and depression: a prospective study of patients with major depressive disorder. Psychosomatics 42 (2001): 229-234.
  7. Kim JH, Lee SJ, Rim HD, et al. The Relationship between Alexithymia and General Symptoms of Patients with Depressive Disorders. Psychiatry Investig 5 (2008): 179-185.
  8. Deborde AS, Berthoz S, Godart N, et al. Relations between alexithymia and anhedonia: a study in eating disordered and control subjects. L'encephale 32 (2006): 83-91.
  9. Zarei J, Besharat MA. Alexithymia and interpersonal problems. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 5 (2010): 619-622.
  10. Dubey A, Pandey R. Mental Health Problems in Alexithymia: Role of Positive and Negative Emotional Experiences, SIS J Proj Psy and Ment Health 20 (2013): 128-136.
  11. Myles LAMK, Emanuele MM. Alexithymia and physical outcomes in psychosomatic subjects: a cross-sectional study. Journal of Mind and Medical Sciences 8 (2021).
  12. Franz M, Popp K, Schaefer R, et al. Alexithymia in the German general population. Soc Psychiat Epidemiol 43 (2008): 54-62.
  13. Mattilaa AK, Salminenc JK, NummiaT, Joukama M. et al. Age is strongly associated with alexithymia in the general population; Journal of Psychosomatic Research 61 (2006): 629-635.
  14. Honkalampi K., Tolmunen T, Hintikka J. et al. The prevalence of alexithymia and its relationship with Youth Self-Report problem scales among Finnish adolescents Comprehensive Psychiatry 50 (2009): 263-268.
  15. Ng CSM, Chan VCW. Prevalence and associated factors of alexithymia among Chinese adolescents in Hong Kong. Psychiatry Research 290 (2020): 113126.
  16. Popa-Velea O, Diaconescu L, Mihailescu A, et al. Burnout and its relationships with alexithymia, stress, and social support among Romanian medical students: A cross-sectional study. Int J Environ Res Public Health 14 (2017): 560.
  17. Dubey A, Pandey R. Mental health problems in alexithymia: Role of positive and negative emotional experiences. Journal of Projective Psychology and Mental Health 20 (2013): 128-136.
  18. Bbasi M, Bagyan MJ, Dehghan H. Cognitive failure and alexithymia and predicting high–risk behaviors of students with learning disabilities. Int J High Risk Behav Addict 3 (2014): 16948.
  19. Online Sample Size Calculator. (Accessed on 4 April 2017).
  20. Bagby RM, Parker JDA, Taylor GJ. The twenty-item Toronto Alexithymia Scale—I. Item selection and cross-validation of the factor structure. APA PsycTests (1994).
  21. Aljaffer MA, Almadani AH, Alghamdi SA, et al. Prevalence and associated factors of alexithymia among medical students: A cross-sectional study from Saudi Arabia. Neurosciences (Riyadh) 27 (2022): 257-262.
  22. Hamaideh S H. Alexithymia among Jordanian university students: Its prevalence and correlates with depression, anxiety, stress, and demographics 2018, Perspective in psychiatric care 54 (2018): 274-280.
  23. Alzahrani SH, Coumaravelou S, Mahmoud I, et al. Prevalence of alexithymia and associated factors among medical students at King Abdulaziz University: a cross-sectional study. Ann Saudi Med 40 (2020): 55-62.
  24. Aleisa MA, Abdullah NS, Alqahtani, et al. Association between Alexithymia and Depression among King Khalid University Medical Students: An Analytical Cross-Sectional Study. Healthcare 10 (2022): 1703.
  25. Zhu Y, Luo T, Liu J, et al. Influencing factors of alexithymia in Chinese medical students: A cross-sectional study. BMC Med Educ 17 (2017): 66.
  26. Khan NT, Mumtaz F. Prevalence of Alexithymia among Undergraduates at Buitems; Epidemiology (Sunnyvale) 7 (2017): 333.
  27. Khan NT. Prevalence of Alexithymia in the General Adult Population of Quetta, Balochistan in Pakistan. Clon Transgen 6 (2017): 160.
  28. Alharthi AM, Almasoudi MA, Alotaibi MB, et al. Prevalence of Alexithymia and the influencing factors among medical students at Umm Al-Qura University: A cross-sectional study. Medical Science 26 (2022): 26e1947.
  29. Fatima A, Ghayas S and Khawar R; Development and Validation of Alexithymia Scale for Pakistani Population, Pakistan Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology. 14 (2016): 3-9.
  30. Le HN, Berenbaum H, Raghavan C. Culture and alexithymia: Mean levels, correlates, and the role of parental socialization of emotions. Emotion 2 (2002): 341-360.
  31. McGillivray L, Becerra R, Harms C. Prevalence and demographic correlates of alexithymia: A comparison between Australian psychiatric and community samples. Journal of clinical psychology 73 (2017): 76-87.
  32. Moriguchi Y, Maeda M, Igarashi T, et al. Age and gender effect on alexithymia in large, Japanese community and clinical samples: A cross-validation study of the Toronto Alexithymia Scale (TAS-20). Biopsychosoc Med (2007): 1-7.
  33. Zaidi SMIH, Arshad M, Yaqoob N. Gender distinction in alexithymia among graduation students of Pakistan. European Journal of Research in Social Sciences 3 (2015): 1950-1956.
  34. Tolmunen T, Lehto SM, Heliste M, et al. Alexithymia is associated with increased cardiovascular mortality in middle-aged Finnish men. Psychosom Med 7 (2010): 187-191.
  35. Kulsoom B, Afsar NA. Stress, anxiety, and depression among medical students in a multiethnic setting. Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat 11 (2015): 1713-1722.
  36. Lyvers M, Holloway N, Needham K, et al. Resilience, alexithymia, and university stress in relation to anxiety and problematic alcohol use among female university students. Aust J Psychol 72 (2020): 59-67.
  37. Bell SL, Audrey S, Gunnell D. et al. The relationship between physical activity, mental wellbeing and symptoms of mental health disorder in adolescents: a cohort study. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 16 (2019): 138.
  38. Dishman RK, Heath GW, Lee I-M. Physical activity epidemiology, 2nd edn Champaign: Human Kinetics (2013).
  39. Biddle S. Physical activity and mental health: evidence is growing. World Psychiatry 15 (2016): 176-177.
  40. Khan MS, Mahmood S, Badshah A, et al. Prevalence of depression, anxiety and their associated factors among medical students in Karachi, Pakistan. J Pak Med Assoc 56 (2006): 583.
  41. Mirza AA, Baig M, Beyari GM, et al. Depression and Anxiety among Medical Students: A Brief Overview. Adv Med Educ Pract 12 (2021): 393-398.
  42. Sagar R, Talwar S, Desai G, et al. Relationship between alexithymia depression: A narrative review, Indian Journal of Psychiatry 63 (2021): 127-133.
  43. Marchesi C, Brusamonti E, Maggini C. Are alexithymia, depression, and anxiety distinct constructs in affective disorders? J Psychosom Res 49 (2000): 43-49.
  44. Sfeir E, Geara C, Hallit S, et al. Alexithymia, aggressive behavior and depression among Lebanese adolescents: A cross-sectional study. Child Adolesc Psychiatry Ment Health 1 (2020): 32.

© 2016-2024, Copyrights Fortune Journals. All Rights Reserved